The Evidence LockerPoggy's case files

Toy Story theories

6 Toy Story theories Poggy has investigated, each filed as a playable case file. Work the three exhibits, name the verdict, then watch the full case on YouTube.

  1. Woody NEVER Fixed Buzz Lightyear (and the Manual Proves It) Case 044 ·

    Woody never fixed Buzz Lightyear: the Toy Story 3 manual calls the deluded Space Ranger his original factory setting, and the self-aware Buzz we love is the mode anyone can switch off.

  2. Toy Story 5's Villain is a LIE (it's actually Jessie) Case 037 ·

    Toy Story 5's real antagonist is Jessie, whose jealousy of Bonnie's new tablet drives every act of harm in the film while the marketed villain simply does her job.

  3. Woody’s Sacrifice was a LIE (and Gabby Gabby proves it) Case 017 ·

    Gabby Gabby's arc in Toy Story 4 plays as a successful operation rather than a redemption: she takes what she wants from Woody, never apologizes, and the film rewards her anyway.

  4. Toy Story 3's Ending is a LIE (and the Note Proves It) Case 014 ·

    Andy never decides to give his toys away in Toy Story 3; Woody forges the instruction that sends him to Bonnie's porch, and Andy thinks his mom wrote it.

  5. Stinky Pete is a CULT LEADER (and Toy Story 3 Proved Him Right) Case 009 ·

    Stinky Pete runs a cult in Toy Story 2, built on a made-up origin story and a lie about himself, and Toy Story 3 later proves his warning about children came true anyway.

  6. Toy Story's Villain is a LIE (and ONE SCENE proves it) Case 004 ·

    Sid Phillips is not the villain of Toy Story: his so-called mutant toys repair a broken Buzz Lightyear, which shows Sid's room is a workshop and Woody's version of events is the real lie.